I tried this on in the store and wanted to love it, but the collar design turned out to be awkward and impractical. It could have been designed similarly but more functionally.

the sleeves on this seeatshirt are really wide. they look like tge shirt version of the barrel jean and its not a good look. returning this and sad

Perfect sweatshirt ruined by gigantic, disproportionate sleeves

Love the fabric and the design is so cute, but the sleeves are awful! The sleeves are so big, I could put 2 arms in them! sadly returned!

I received the form knit shawl collar sweatshirt a couple of days ago, tried it on and returned it right away. I love the design but the fabric is a total letdown! Over the past few seasons, Athleta sweatshirt's cotton content has decreased and has …

this would be so cute if the shoulders/sleeves we not so ridiculously large. even the xxs engulfed me and looked very out of proportion. i agree with another reviewer who is tired of the oversized look. It does not flatter most people and it’s hard t…

im sad about this top as i live the zip collar. 5,4” 135 and tgs xxs was huge on mt. the arms are long and its long and boxy. im tired of thd oversized trend. The collar is amazibg and i hope we see this one made a bit more sleek

Very well made. Very stylish. I plan to wear it just like the picture with a button down white top underneath.

Wow! This is just a stunning top! So stunning in fact I went back and bought the remaining 2 colors. Very flattering on and in my opinion very versatile. My tts is typically a size medium and based on the description and the other reviews, I size…

I love this! It’s nice enough that I can wear it to work. It does run large. I usually wear a large, ordered a medium because I am losing weight and the medium fits great. I will probably need it in a small. Anyway, the fabric is so nice! It has a sl…