I LOVED this ribbed tank so much that I bought another! I am 5'2", weigh120 pounds and ordered an XS. I had the luxury of trying this on in the Athleta store for my first purchase so I knew it fit well. I don't agree that it's low cut and I tried it on with a push up bra! I am also a 32D so I wouldn't want too much showing and this provided full coverage. The material is ultra soft and yes, it is more form fitting; however, it hugs the body loosely not too tight. I believe finding your right size is the key to loving this top. I highly recommend!

I love the fabric, length, & sweetheart look. Unfortunately, the regular cut makes it hang too low on top, so I had to return it. Short women need more sizing options. More color choices would be great, too.

I wanted to love this cream/ivory tank. The sweetheart neckline is a beautiful idea, the fabric feels soft and luxurious, and the cropped length is actually great for shorter torsos like mine. Unfortunately, the fit did not work for me. The neckline was much too low, and the fabric was so snug that it showed every ripple, wrinkle, and muscle underneath. The ivory color was also a bit see-through, which made the fit issues even more noticeable. For reference, I'm 5'3", 128 lbs, with an athletic build, and I usually wear XXS or XS in Athleta tops. I may have needed a Small for comfort through the body, but with how low the neckline was, sizing up would have made the top even more revealing. Sadly, this one just wasn't wearable for me in ivory.