I am puzzled by Athleta's decision to make only cropped tops fo a cold season set (with the waffle joggers). I will be returning this just like the other waffle long sleeves as they're both too short and will not be useful in cooler weather. Unfortunate since I love the fabric and the colours.

This is a sweater that looks good and feels good. But the most important thing is it's "shortcomings". Yes, it is cropped short, so ask yourself how much warmth you will be getting. The the sleeves come exactly to the wrist on an average size person. I am 5' 5" and weigh 125 pounds & consistently wear a size Sm in Regular. This sweater works well under a coat that doesn't have a hood or with outerwear that can provide additional warmth.