I've gone back and forth on whether to keep or return. Ultimately I think I've decided to keep them. Some of the things I don't like: the 2 blacks don't match but when they're on, it's not as noticeable. They say they're mid-rise, but they are high-rise! Which I don't like and is main reason I was g...oing to return them. I just find high-rise uncomfortable & unflattering. And they go in considerably at the waist, so if you hold them up, they are a definite hourglass shape. I'm pretty straight and carry a little extra in my middle so I find the waist going in not that pleasant and I really don't know many people actually built that way...you'd have to have a really small waist to normal hips, or have really large hips. Why I'm deciding to keep them: they fill a need for a dressier pant but with the legging comfort and some stretch. I also love that they're long...I got the tall. I like my leggings to bunch up a small amount on top of my foot and these do that perfectly. I'm counting on losing a bit of weight in my mid-section then I think these will be perfect! For reference, I'm 5'6" about 120lbs and got the tall. I don't think I would have liked the regular near as much. Not a fan of the 7/8 length or my ankles showing and being cold in the Chicago winter! These look cute being a bit longer.